7 Delicious Restaurants in Hershey, PA as Picked by a Local

Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links. We will make a small commission from these links if you order something at no additional cost to you.

For the last seven years, I’ve lived in Dauphin County, and I’ve regularly found myself eating at the many different the restaurants in Hershey, PA.

During that time, I’ve eaten at some fantastic spots, so I figured I’d put together this list featuring a few of my places to eat in Hershey.

So, whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite or a visitor looking for somewhere to eat between attractions, here are a few great spots to check out.

The Forebay

Forebay is one of my favorite restaurants in Hershey, PA
The Forebay at the Hershey Lodge offers high-end food in a classy environment.

If you are looking for a delicious higher-end meal in Hershey, don’t miss The Forebay at the Hershey Lodge.

Forebay is the perfect way to end a day after checking out the best things to do in Hershey, PA because it offers incredibly delicious food in an upscale, but comfortable setting. Their menu features incredible steaks as well as other delicious entrees like seafood, baby back ribs, and pasta.

Given that this is a Hershey’s property, don’t leave without trying their amazing chocolate martini’s (the Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup one is phenomenal) and their delicious desserts.

Note that Forebay is only open for dinner.

Troegs Independent Brewing

Food at Troegs Brewery in Hershey, PA
Troegs features amazing food and some of the best beers in Pennsylvania.

When I’m trying to figure out where to eat in Hershey, PA, there’s nowhere that I end up more frequently than Troegs Independent Brewing.

Troegs’ brewery is located less than a mile northwest of Hersheypark and is one of the largest and best breweries in PA. However, they aren’t just a great brewery; they also make some pretty phenomenal food.

Interestingly, Troegs has what they call a Snack Bar, where you have to go up and place your order and then return to get your prepared food. However, this probably will be the only snack bar you’ll ever visit that has dishes like duck confit, charcuterie, oysters, and rack of lamb.

Of course, for those that aren’t into fancy food, Troegs features absolutely fantastic hop fries, braised brisket, and a pretzel that’s bigger than your head.

It’s also worth noting that Troegs is one of the most kid-friendly places to eat in Hershey.

Fenicci’s

Ghost pepper wings at Fenicci's in Hershey, Pennsylvania
If you’re feeling brave, the ghost pepper wings at Fenicci’s are amazing.

Located in downtown Hershey, Fenicci’s has been a staple of the Hershey dining scene since 1935.

Fenicci’s features great Italian food and uses decades-old sauce recipes. They were even the first restaurant in town to serve pizza back in 1947. However, while Fenicci’s celebrates their past, they definitely don’t rely on it. 

Popular dishes that I’ve enjoyed include their meatballs, lasagna, and the upside-down pizza, but everything I’ve seen come from the kitchen looks delicious.

If you want to live dangerously, try their ghost pepper wings made from ghost peppers grown in the owner’s garden. While they are tear-inducing spicy, the flavor is out of this world.

Smoked Bar and Grill

If you want BBQ in Hershey, look no further than Smoked Bar and Grill. While they offer other entrees like salads, tacos, and burgers, the real star of their menu is their BBQ sandwiches.

Smoked features seven different BBQ sandwiches ranging from traditional to rather unique (Pickled brisket, anyone?).

Smoked also features one of the best beer lists in Hershey, so this is a great spot to check out if you want a beer, but don’t want to venture to a brewery.

The Chocolate Avenue Grill

The hamburgers at the Chocolate Avenue Grill make it one of my favorite places to eat in Hershey, PA
The Chocolate Avenue Grill offers a wide variety of delicious food.

If you’re looking for a delicious, but unpretentious meal, the Chocolate Avenue Grill is a great choice.

The Chocolate Avenue Grill offers a broad menu that features everything from chicken wraps to lobster. During my visit here, my wife and I ordered a burger and a Reuben, both of which were incredibly delicious.

Make sure to save some room for dessert, as the Chocolate Avenue Grill has some fantastic options.

Iron Hill Brewery and Restaurant

Nachos at Iron Hill in Hershey, PA during Happy Hour
Iron Hill features a great Happy Hour with amazing prices on appetizers.

Iron Hill Brewery and Restaurant is the second brewery in Hershey and is located in downtown Hershey. To be perfectly honest, neither their beers nor their food is as good as what you’ll find at Troegs. However, if you’re looking for another brewery to visit, Iron Hill is a solid choice.

My favorite aspect of Iron Hill is their great Happy Hour, which runs from 4-6pm Monday-Friday. During Happy Hour, they offer some great discounts on appetizers and beers. I especially love the soft pretzel sticks, fried Brussel sprouts, and the nachos.

Of course, they also have a full menu that’s available throughout the day for those looking for a bit more food.

Duck Donuts

Duck Donuts is a great spot for breakfast in Hershey
Duck Donuts is kid-approved.

If you’ve ever traveled to the Outer Banks of North Carolina, you’re probably familiar with Duck Donuts. However, since this company is based in the Harrisburg area, I figured I could get away with including this local chain on the list.

If you’ve never had Duck Donuts, they are made to order with a variety of toppings and flavorings. Without a doubt, their warm donuts are a fantastic treat whether you are eating them for breakfast, a snack, or dessert.

Do you have a favorite restaurant in Hershey, PA that didn’t make my list? Let me know in the comments below.

Looking for more things to do near Hershey? Check out Indian Echo Caverns, The Hershey Story, the Spa at the Hotel Hershey, and the Antique Automobile Club of America Museum.

You can also check out the best breweries in the Harrisburg and Hershey area.

Great places to stay near Harrisburg and Hershey


Click the map to see more nearby things to do

Map of PA Dutch Country"

More nearby places to explore

Find more things to do in Pennsylvania Dutch Country

7 thoughts on “7 Delicious Restaurants in Hershey, PA as Picked by a Local”

Leave a Comment